“Christmas has now come”?

“Thanksgiving is over, and now Christmas has come . . .”

Those were some of the words from an offertory prayer I heard on a broadcast of a church service the other night.  It was a tape-delayed broadcast from a local church, and it was their service from this past Sunday (26 Nov.).  The sanctuary was decorated for Christmas, they sang Christmas songs, and the sermon was a Christmas sermon.  The preacher kept saying, “As we celebrate Christmas . . .”

Did I miss something?  Christmas has come?  As we celebrate Christmas?

For those of you who think that church calendar stuff is esoteric and not practical, look no further than the church service I observed.  This is nothing more than the church following the world, rather than the other way around.  Christmas is a Christian holiday.  Retailers invented the “shopping season” that begins the day after Thanksgiving, not the church.  The Sunday after Thanksgiving, no one could (or should) have said “Christmas has now come.” The season of preparation for Christmas (Advent) had not even begun by last Sunday.  Last Sunday was Christ the King (or the Reign of Christ) Sunday, a pretty important doctrine on its own, I think.  This coming Sunday is the beginning of Advent, but even so, we can’t (or shouldn’t) say “Christmas has now come” until Christmas Eve.

As those who are “redeeming the time”, we should mark time differently from the world.  Our priorities should be different from those of the retailers.  Christian tradition regarding not only Christmas, but all holy days, follows this pattern:  prepare–celebrate–reflect.  During Advent, we prepare ourselves spiritually (and otherwise) to celebrate Christ’s birth.  During the Twelve Days of Christmas (which begin, rather than end, on 25 December), we celebrate.  On Epiphany and the days afterward, we reflect on the relevance of Christmas in our lives.  Similarly, during Lent and Holy Week we prepare.  During the Great Fifty Days of Easter we celebrate.  On Pentecost and the Sundays afterward we reflect on what it means to have the Risen Christ in our midst (through the Holy Spirit).  Celebration without preparation is superficial.  Maybe that’s why Evangelicals rarely get any deeper than “keep Christ in Christmas” or “Jesus is the reason for the season” at this time of year.  Actually, Jesus is not the reason for the season most Evangelicals think is the “Christmas season”:  money is the reason for the “shopping season.”

Understanding the Church Year is important because the way we mark time can bring us spiritual health.  “Practical” theology is theology that is put into practice.  We need to get past this idea that only things with titles like “10 Easy Steps to Spiritual Growth” are “practical.”  Understanding how we should mark time as God’s people is intensely practical:  it is one of the most practical subjects of all, because we live in time.  Applying our faith to the way we mark time is where we put feet to our faith:  the way we mark time as the church sets us apart as a counter-culture, in the world but not of the world.  Salt and light.  City on a hill.  Etc., etc.

Throwing up our hands and calling the “shopping season” Christmas is ridiculous.  Just as the culture itself is beginning to say “enough!” to the retailers’ attempts to push Christmas back earlier and earlier every year (several articles to that end have appeared in major publications in the past few months), Evangelicals are once again proving that no one is more “of the world, but not in it” than they are.  Ridiculous.  And sad.

If the church would refuse to recognize the “shopping season” and purposefully mark time the way Christians have marked time for centuries (preparation–celebration–reflection), we wouldn’t have to run around yelling “keep Christ in Christmas.” Christ has always been in Christmas:  the real Christmas.  Who cares whether or not the retailers keep Christ in their “shopping season”?  They can have their shopping season.   The church has Christmas:  it always has and it always will.   We simply need to tell the world how Christmas is to be celebrated, not allow them to dictate its celebration to us.

After all, it was ours to begin with, not theirs.


About revjatb

I am a father of six who is trying to do his best! My interests are varied. I have one blog, KnowTea, that is primarily focused on liturgy and worship and another one, Bengtsson's Baking, that is about, well, baking! I hope you enjoy both of them, and if you have any questions, please contact me!
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to “Christmas has now come”?

  1. Cancerman says:

    You are right. How are we to teach others about Christ and Christmas when we don’t understand it ourselves.

  2. RevJATB says:

    I just found this comment on another blog:

    Speaking as a Christian clergyman, two points need to be made:

    1. The Puritans who settled this country regarded Christmas as a pagan holiday that was forbidden to “true Christians” (Catholics and Anglicans being considered pagans and not real Christians) and, in fact, in most of the New England colonies, the celebration of Christmas was a criminal offense.
    2. Liturgical Christians (Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Lutheran) observe a penitential preparation period, Advent, from the fourth Sunday before Christmas until December 24. During this period, Christmas greetings and music are inappropriate. Christmas begins on the evening of December 24 and continues through January 6 (Dec 25 – Jan 5 are the ‘Twelve Days of Christmas’).

    The AFA and other idiots who are waging this “war for Christmas” are basically arguing for the sacredness of the secular holiday celebration that is the creation of American department stores for the purpose of making money and which is not actually based in Christian tradition.

    As someone once said, the religious right is to true religion what paint-by-number is to great art.

    Tim Cravens, Bishop, Independent Catholic Christian Church

    URL: http://www.waynebesen.com/2006/11/merry-christmas.html

  3. Sara says:

    great post. this is exactly how i feel and exactly why i think the “war on christmas” is so laughable.

    having worked holiday retail just about every year of my adult life except the past two, it’s an issue i’ve thought a lot about. especially working holiday retail in new york, where one can, in fact, reasonably expect to encounter shoppers of all faiths. i’m no fan of the “happy holidays” greeting, so i just started saying what i said during the rest of the year — “enjoy your day”. what’s it to me whether someone is out shopping for Christmas/Chanukah/Kwanzaa/Yule/Whatever gifts, or for some other occasion entirely?

  4. MoDrig3 says:

    JATB: I always enjoy reading your stuff. One point grabbed my attention:

    I was at the Catalyst conference in October. Donald Miller (author of “Blue Like Jazz” and “Searching for God Knows What”) spoke and mentioned as an aside that very kind of thing. “5 keys to a happy marriage” was what he said, then unpacked it this way: He asked those in the audience who were married (he’s not) if there were really only 5, then said that his friends who were married would say that it’s more like 37 and it’s not the same 37 every day.

    Part of his point was that when we give people “3 keys to spiritual growth” and they don’t fit the locks they are wrestling with, then there is a risk that they will think that it’s because there’s something wrong with them or that there’s something wrong with the Savior we are trying to help them to encounter. The Christian life is far more organic and messy than the messages we are tempted to preach indicates. He likened the oversimplification of the Gospel that doesn’t stand the test of life to spiritual snake-oil.

    Sometimes I long for the ordered, measured contemplation that the liturgical calendar can bring to life. On the other hand, I wouldn’t go so far as to eliminate all “Christmas” hymns from Advent … saving them until Christmas eve as some of our most liturgical brethren do. Some of the content of those hymns actually assists in the preparation for the experience. I do hate it when radio stations begin playing Christmas music before Thanksgiving … or even on Thanksgiving Day. And I have NEVER understood year-round Christmas stores. That’s just wrong in so many ways.

    Interesting stuff.

    Shalom, my brother.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s